The Legend of the Oly Koeks

Week #10 – Literature 


This week was right up my alley. Do I use too many cliches? Sorry. Sometimes they can be fun. 

Anyway, when this theme was announced, I knew exactly what I was going to make. 

See, a few years ago while I was studying for my Praxis II exam (the exam teachers have to take to prove they know their subject), I spent a lot of time reading American Literature. I read Uncle Tom’s Cabin, The Old Man and the Sea, The Great Gatsby, etc… And I loved them all. But one stuck out. 

The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, by Washington Irving,  popped into my head right away. Why? There is an entire chapter devoted to the various foods that our protagonist, Ichabod Crane, gluttons himself upon at a party. 

OlyKoeks3 (1)

But I also think it stuck out because it makes me long for the idyllic days of my childhood. I remember dressing up for Halloween, going trick-or-treating, and bobbing for apples – and Sleepy Hollow definitely fits the bill for “things that go along with that time of year.” The book makes me want to do those same things with my own kids. 

So I picked a pastry from the book that I had never heard of. I assumed it was an old pastry, brought over to the US from somewhere long, long ago. And I was right. 

OlyKoeks3 (7)

Turns out the Dutch brought over the forerunner to the doughnut – an Oly Koek. Oly Koek means “oil cake,” and as you probably guessed, they are cakes that have been fried in oil. 

They are the forerunner to the doughnut because there’s no hole in them. Instead, they are stuffed with dried fruits before frying. If you try to fry them without stuffing them, they burn before cooking the whole way through. By stuffing them, you end up with perfectly cooked dough and a tasty treat inside. 

OlyKoeks3 (8)

And while I had never heard of them, my friend Tina grew up eating Oly Koeks. She grew up in Michigan. I grew up in PA. I guess the Pennsylvania Dutch were a bit different from the Michigan Dutch. 

Anyway, these were quite the tasty treat – even if I did overcook mine just a bit. I’ll be making these again when my daughter and (eventual) future children are old enough to help me out. And we’ll eat them outside amongst the falling leaves while wearing our sweaters and scarves, reading about Ichabod, and enjoying the sweet days of childhood. 

OlyKoeks3 (10)

Oly Koeks
Inspired by The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Oly Koeks are deep fried dough balls stuffed with apple brandy-soaked dried fruits. Perfect for that autumn chill!
Write a review
  1. 1 c. dried fruit pieces
  2. 1/8 c. apple brandy
  3. 1 and a half packets dry yeast
  4. 1/2 c. warm water
  5. 1 c. whole milk
  6. 4 tbsp. butter
  7. 1 egg white, beaten
  8. 2 egg yolks
  9. 1/2 c. sugar
  10. 1/2 tsp. nutmeg
  11. 3-4 c. flour
  12. powdered sugar
  1. Soak the dried fruit in the brandy overnight.
  2. Mix together the yeast and the water. Set aside in a warm place. Meanwhile, warm the milk and the butter. When butter is melted, remove from stove top.
  3. Place the eggs, sugar, and nutmeg in a mixing bowl and stir together. Add the yeast and mix well. Mix in flour, a bit at a time until the mixture resembles a soft dough (not too sticky). Set aside in a warm place, cover with a wet towel, and allow to rise for 1 hour.
  4. After an hour, drain brandy from fruit. Grab an egg shaped amount of dough, roll into a ball and make a well in the middle. Stuff the dough with fruit mixture, and roll back up making sure fruit is securely covered.
  5. Drop into large pot of oil and cook until golden brown. Remove with a wooden spoon, and place on a wire rack to cool. Top with powdered sugar (confectioner's). Eat.
  1. It's probably a good idea to use a candy thermometer to monitor how hot your oil is. My oil got too hot, which is why these came out a little more cooked that I would have preferred.
Supper's in the Skillet

About Chrissy

Hi! I'm Chrissy. I'm a 31 year old cast-iron (pretty much) newbie. I'm learning more as I go and screwing up quite a bit along the way. I'm a northern girl (Yay, PA!) who has been transplanted to the south and am trying to embrace becoming a southern lady. Hence the cast-iron pan. I've never made my own biscuits and I have no idea what a dutch baby is. But you can bet that I'll figure all of that out. So stick around and see what happens as I learn the in- and-outs of cooking with cast-iron.
52 Weeks of Cooking, Dessert, Non-Skillet, Seasonal, Snacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *